Types of RetainersClear, Hawley or Permanent?

Types of Retainers: Clear, Hawley and Permanent Retainers Compared

There are three main types of retainers: clear plastic retainers, Hawley retainers and permanent (bonded) retainers. Clear and Hawley retainers are removable, while a permanent retainer is a thin wire fixed behind your front teeth. Each one holds your teeth in their new position after braces or aligners, and your dentist or orthodontist will recommend the type that suits your bite and daily habits.

Below, we compare them on looks, comfort, cleaning and durability, so you can have a more useful conversation with your dentist.

Why do you need a retainer after braces or aligners?

Moving your teeth is only half the job. Once treatment ends, the gums and bone around each tooth need time to settle, and teeth naturally tend to drift back toward their old positions.

A retainer holds them steady while that happens, and for a long time after. As our guide to retainers after clear aligners explains, retention is not optional. It is the final step of any well-managed treatment plan.

Teeth can also shift slowly with age, which is why many dentists ask patients to keep wearing a retainer at night for the long term. If you have wondered whether aligners fix teeth permanently, the honest answer is that lasting results depend on retention.

What are the main types of retainers?

Retainers fall into two groups: removable ones that you take in and out, and fixed ones that your dentist bonds in place. Within those groups, there are three types of retainers that most patients hear about.

What is a clear retainer?

A clear retainer is a thin, transparent plastic tray made to fit the exact shape of your teeth. It looks a lot like a clear aligner, but its job is different. An aligner moves teeth in small steps, while a retainer simply holds them still.

Our comparison of aligners, retainers, veneers and crowns explains that difference in more detail. You can also read why clear retainers matter after aligner treatment.

Clear retainers are light and hard to notice. You take them out to eat or drink anything other than plain water, and brush your teeth before putting them back in.

What is a Hawley retainer?

A Hawley retainer is the classic design. It has an acrylic base that sits against the roof of your mouth or behind your lower teeth, with a thin metal wire running across the front of your teeth. Cleveland Clinic describes it simply as a piece of wire attached to plastic or acrylic.

Hawley retainers are sturdy, and your dentist can often adjust them. The wire across your front teeth is visible, though, and some people notice a slight change in their speech for the first few days.

What is a permanent retainer?

A permanent retainer, also called a bonded or fixed retainer, is a thin wire glued to the inside surfaces of your front teeth. It is usually placed behind the lower front teeth, and sometimes behind the upper ones too.

Because you cannot take it out, it works around the clock without you having to remember it. The trade-off is that cleaning around the wire takes extra effort every day.

Clear vs Hawley vs permanent retainers: how do they compare?

Here is how the three types usually compare. Your own experience will depend on your teeth and your habits.

  • Appearance: Clear retainers are hard to notice, Hawley retainers show a wire across the front teeth, and permanent retainers sit hidden behind the teeth.
  • Comfort: Clear retainers feel thin and light. Hawley retainers cover more of the mouth, and a permanent retainer takes your tongue a few days to get used to.
  • Cleaning: Clear and Hawley retainers come out for cleaning. A permanent retainer needs careful brushing and flossing around the wire every day.
  • Durability: Clear plastic can crack, scratch or warp with heat over time. Hawley retainers are usually sturdier, and a bonded wire can come loose or break if you bite something hard.
  • Daily effort: Removable retainers only work when you wear them, and they are easy to misplace. A permanent retainer works all the time, as long as it stays intact.
  • Adjustments: Hawley retainers can often be adjusted. Clear retainers usually need to be remade if the fit changes.

Which type of retainer is best for you?

There is no single best option. The American Association of Orthodontists notes that clear retainers are lightweight and harder to see than Hawley retainers, while fixed retainers remove the worry of a removable retainer being lost or left unworn. Your dentist weighs points like these:

  • Your original problem: Teeth that were very crowded, or gaps that were closed, may need extra support to stay in place.
  • Your bite: A deep bite or another bite issue can affect where a wire or tray can sit comfortably.
  • Your habits: If you grind your teeth at night, or know you might forget a removable retainer, the advice may change.
  • Your oral hygiene: A permanent retainer suits people who are ready to floss around it carefully every day.
  • Your routine: Long workdays, travel and late-night wedding functions can make a removable retainer easy to forget.

Your dentist may also combine two types. One pairing some dentists use is a permanent retainer behind the lower front teeth with a removable retainer for the upper teeth. The type you choose can also affect retainer cost, so it is worth discussing both together.

Are retainers different after aligners and after braces?

The same three types are used after both treatments. After clear aligners, many patients find a clear retainer feels familiar, because it fits much like the trays they wore 20 to 22 hours a day.

If you are treated with ClearPath aligners, ask your ClearPath provider which retainer they recommend for your case.

How do you look after each type of retainer?

A few care basics apply to all three types:

  • Clean it daily: Brush a removable retainer gently with a soft brush and cool or lukewarm water, and brush and floss carefully around a bonded wire.
  • Keep it away from heat: Hot water, a parked car in summer or a spot near the stove can warp plastic.
  • Use the case: Wrapping a retainer in a tissue at a dinner or dholki is one of the easiest ways to lose it.
  • Report problems early: A crack, a loose wire or a change in fit is a reason to call your dentist, not to wait.

Our guide to retainers after braces and aligners covers wear schedules and care in more detail.

Key Takeaways

  • The three main types of retainers are clear plastic, Hawley and permanent (bonded) retainers.
  • Clear and Hawley retainers are removable, while a permanent retainer is a wire fixed behind your front teeth.
  • Each type has trade-offs in appearance, comfort, cleaning and durability.
  • Your dentist may recommend one type or a combination, based on your teeth, bite and habits.
  • Whichever type you get, wearing it as directed is what keeps your new smile in place.
Which type of retainer is the most comfortable?

Many people find clear retainers the most comfortable because they are thin and light, but comfort varies from person to person. Any new retainer can feel tight or unusual for the first few days.

Is a clear retainer the same as a clear aligner?

No. They look similar, but an aligner is designed to move teeth gradually, while a retainer holds them in their final position.

Can I switch from one type of retainer to another?

Often, yes. Your dentist can check your teeth and advise whether a different type would suit you better.

Do I need to wear a retainer forever?

Most dentists recommend long-term retainer wear, usually mainly at night after an initial period, because teeth can shift over time. Your dentist will set your schedule.

How much does a retainer cost?

It depends on the type, how many you need and your treatment plan. Your dentist can give you an exact quote after checking your teeth.

Not sure which retainer would suit you, or whether clear aligners are right for your teeth? Talk to a ClearPath provider near you, or start with the eligibility check at https://patient.clearpathortho.com/am-i-a-candidate.